Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Beware of unchecked thinking

So web 2.0 is the great democratiser. There has always been a hierarchy of knowledge, scholarly thinking has always been held in high regard. Blame the ancient Greeks I guess.

Library 2.0 recognises that information and knowledge isn't always in a printed format. (Written, but not printed.) In someways, 2.0 harps back to a time when printed material was not vastly available. The printing press paved the way for democratising knowledge, making the dissemination of information cheap and quick. Like a historically verbal tradition, 2.0 takes advantage of community knowledge. Except in the 21st century, literacy rates are already established. So society doesn't have to overhaul itself to use the information. Which might be it's problem. Why adapt if it isn't critical?

However, in general, a population inherently has to believe that those inhabiting the upper echelons of that society have somehow earned their place. That anyone above you warrants respects, (that the parents knows more...) the web throws out these notions. Knowledge is no longer slowly acquired, but pours in. My scepticism of web technologies is that is it too democratic. Everyone is an expert, and has valid opinions. Myspace is a testament to stupid people with web access.

Are we in fact getting stupider by our increased supply of information. And is information enough? We receive information, but need knowledge. I can't remember who said
"don't speak, unless you can improve the silence".
Information is a lot like junk mail, you can't not be subjected to it. Information no longer has to be of any substance. Scholarly thinking, mediated, and acquired gradually has become the rude dictator. Preventing us all from our destinies as great philosophers.

Here's another quote I found, while trying to credit the previous one
"If you wouldn't write it and sign it, don't say it". Earl Wilson

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Great quotes and reall good feedback! Glad to see you are moving along towards taht mp3 player! Keep up the good work! :)

Anonymous said...

haha, forgive my bad spelling :)